This is a list of the players who have won the Molten Defensive Player of the Year Award multiple times.

Most Times Winner

Wins	Players	Seasons
1	Charles Thompson	2024-25
1	Tarik Phillip	2025-26

Most Times Winner (Franchise)

Wins	Franchise	Winners
1	Leicester Riders	Charles Thompson (2024-25)
1	London Lions	Tarik Phillip (2025-26)