This is a list of the players who have appeared in the Molten Defensive Team of the Year multiple times.
Most Appearances
| Appearances | Player | Seasons |
| 1 | Charles Thompson | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Josh Ward-Hibbert | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Alen Hadzibegovic | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Larry Austin Jr. | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Dame Adelekun | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Deane Williams | 2025-26 |
| 1 | Tarik Phillip | 2025-26 |
| 1 | Chaundee Brown Jr | 2025-26 |
| 1 | LaQuincy Rideau | 2025-26 |
| 1 | Michael Graham | 2025-26 |
Most Team Members (Franchise)
| Players | Team |
| 3 (2025-26) | London Lions |
Only teams with 2+ members of a Molten Defensive Team of the Year are listed.