This is a list of the players who have won the Molten Community Champion of the Year Award multiple times.
Most Times Winner
| Wins | Players | Seasons |
| 1 | Nick Lewis | 2024-25 |
| 1 | Kyle Jimenez | 2025-26 |
Most Times Winner (Franchise)
| Wins | Franchise | Winners |
| 1 | Manchester Basketball | Nick Lewis (2024-25) |
| 1 | Caledonia Gladiators | Kyle Jimenez (2025-26) |